ST AUGUSTINE ON THE ONLY WAY TO CONTROL THE SEXUAL APPETITE
In 8 years time, 1,600 years will have passed since St Augustine died on August 28th, in the year 430. Augustine's influence still looms large over us today, and while he lived a long time ago, human nature never changes and his advice on controlling the carnal is as instructive now as it was then. Augustine was hostage to his own fleshly desires, and he lamented, "the habit of satisfying an insatiable appetite grievously tormented me, its captive". His sainted mother, Monica orchestrated for him to be married so that he could have relations within marriage which would thereby not be sinful. Augustine, however, did not want to marry, in fact, he was the opposite of those of us who feel we were made for marriage and he admitted, "I was not so much a lover of marriage as a slave to lust".
While he waited for his fiancée to come of age, his mistress (the mother of his son) left him for good because she was going to be ditched anyway in favor of a wife and her leaving caused Augustine heartbreak, "My heart still clung to her: it was pierced and wounded within me, and the wound drew blood from it." Nonetheless instead of waiting to get married, Augustine took a second mistress, and he later wrote, "By her my soul's disease would be fostered...not yet healed within me was that wound which had been made by the cutting away of my former companion."
Augustine's great friend, Alypius kept Augustine from getting married because he felt it would interfere with Augustine's quest for wisdom. Alypius had flirted with sex in early adolescence after which he had supplanted his sex drive with an insatiable desire for knowledge. He was chaste at a time when Augustine despaired of ever being chaste. Augustine later confessed that he played the role of the devil in the life of Alypius, because he taunted the younger man with the idea that he had only had sneaky, quick sex and thus he could not understand the lures of the flesh. While Augustine thought he could never be continent and while Alypius was happily in love with books and indifferent to sex, neither of them desired marriage, as Augustine made clear, "For whatever conjugal dignity there is in the duty of well-ordered marriage and in raising children, it attracted neither of us."
A deeper reading of The Confessions of St Augustine (which I've just done) informs as to the vicissitudes of Augustine's sexual addiction. His enslavement was enabled because he was owned by an error; he thought he could overcome his problem on his own, "I believed that continence lay within a man's own powers, and such powers I was not conscious of within myself." He had to discover that it is the Lord and the Lord alone who gives the gift for control over the sexual appetite, "I was so foolish that I did not know that, as it is written, no man can be continent unless You grant it to him." Augustine was referring to Wisdom 8:21, "And as I knew that I could not be otherwise continent, except God gave it, and this was also a point of wisdom to know whose gift it was."
Augustine asked for this grace, was given it so generously that he became totally chaste, which even to this day is an astounding testament to recovery from a very pernicious case of sex addiction.
We live in an age when sex addiction is largely treated by therapy, support groups and even rehab, if you can afford it. These may all be good and necessary, but they are part of the healing, they are not the Healer and no medicine can substitute for that which cured Augustine: asking the Lord for the gift to be chaste/in control of our sexual appetite. I've heard it said that sex addiction is not as fatal as other addictions, but here I really beg to differ. In my younger days, I was very close to someone who was an astonishingly alluring and influential person who had, ahem, plenty of offers. I soon discovered that they had quite a problem, however, and I became aware of a web of secrecy that shrouded a lifestyle which took large sums of money to maintain and involved making enemies of people who were too hurt (and used) to forget. All the while, they complained to me that they could not find a lasting love.
Their conscience was disabled and they felt nothing when they broke up a relationship and they were blithe and seemingly unaware of the injury they did themselves until they found a very willing partner who they did not know very well before becoming intimate - and that's when they discovered the person was brutally violent and capable of the worst. They survived, and it really was miraculous, but it caused me to think that if one percent of the population is psychopathic and if a sex addict loses all ability to judge the person who is inviting them home in the interest of getting their fix, then it really is only a matter of time before they meet the wrong person.
The person I knew did have a conversion and found a wonderful confessor, and they did as Augustine and asked for a special grace because even though they had been very deeply harmed, they would have otherwise gone back to that way of living when the wounds healed. And while our relationship had ups and downs, we later made amends and are on good terms now. I wish I'd had the maturity and life experience to help them when they were so direly addicted, but they really didn't respect me enough to listen, and I saw that it is the person who need ask for the gift from God to be in charge of their body, just as Augustine did.
You may wish to pray the litany to St Augustine for your private intentions.
This post was informed by The Confessions of St Augustine. The classic painting of Augustine was executed by Philippe de Champaigne.
Thank you for addressing a sensitive subject vis-à-vis St. Augustine. That the afflicted needs to be the one to ask God for the gift, reminds me of the great scene in C.S. Lewis' book, "The Great Divorce" when the angel of God wants to kill the lizard (demon, really) of lust, but needs the person's permission to do so... A great book and a wonderful lesson about how human freedom and God's mercy/assistance interplay.
ReplyDeleteMary, good post. And, I must say, I appreciate the comment above referencing the issue of lust in that superb work, The Great Divorce.
ReplyDeleteSince all is grace from God (See Ephesians), it does follow that the grace of continence/ chastity comes from God. Some get it overnight, others through a long purgation. One must want to change, repent of the lifestyle, and ask for God's grace to change and persevere in this.
I never thought that getting married was the solution to lust. One enters marriage because it is a vocation. At the same time, we need to keep in mind that an addict will just commit adultery and abuse his/her spouse, so entering marriage for the sake of a false chastity is not necessarily the best solution.
Notice that initially Augustine did NOT want to change his lifestyle. We all remember, or should know, his infamous prayer, variously translated, but one translation is:
Make me chaste Lord, but not yet [so I can enjoy this sin some more]
I often thought of how hurt the first concubine was. He loved her and she loved him. I hope she made it into heaven. When reading the Confessions, Augustine comes across as a user, who used this woman for his own gratification.
As you have touched upon above, Mary, there is a lot to unpack in Augustine's Confessions, which of course why it is one of the greatest works ever outside of the Bible. Thank you for this great column, a lot to think about.
Dear James,
DeleteThank you for your superb comment. I feel this intense call to immerse myself in all things Augustine.
Oh how I feel for Augustine's first concubine! I believe Augustine loved her and at the same time used her, but the second mistress was not loved but purely an object of lust. But Augustine wanted to marry neither of his mistresses or his fiancée, and his engagement was something of a delay tactic and means to get Monica to stop pestering him about his promiscuity.
I fully concur that marriage is not the antidote to sexual addiction, and many cases of spousal abuse can be traced to one of the partners being a bully in the bedroom and subjecting the other to abuse in a bid to get what they want. Such marriage mar the marriages of those around them because if one spouse is abusing the other even to the point of sexual violence, perhaps under the pretext of obedience, then they may force the other to leave and this makes a mockery of the order of obedience between husband and wife and makes others in their circle doubt to this effect, "Well, they were a couple where the wife wanted to obey and yet they broke up".
PS - I think I'm only scratching the surface of Confessions!
Why didn t Augustine marry the woman he had a child with ( named Adeodatus --given by God ). Maybe because they belonged to different classes of society.
ReplyDeleteor he didn t want the responsibilities that came with marriage.
Entering a marriage only to satisfy lust is treating the wife as an object again cultural practices i guess.
I read the Monica made the mistress leave and arranged the marriage. And keeping the son.
ReplyDeleteGod bless you
ReplyDeleteA good point you bring out about asking God for continence, as only he can give it.
ReplyDeleteIn your telling of your friend who had a sex addiction problem, I wish you had said whether it was a man or a woman, and definitely not referred to this person as "they." Why were you keeping it a secret? Men and women are different. Sex is the first thing you notice about a person and the last thing you forget.
Hi there, Thank you for your close reading of my post. No, it's not that I'm keeping the sex of the sex addict secret per se, but I knew this person very well for many years and while they suffered a dreadful public humiliation, I want to write in a way that preserves their anonymity and not disclosing if they are a man or a woman is my way of doing that, also it concentrates the message on the addiction and the remedy that comes by way of asking the Lord for the grace.
DeleteAlso, I have known men and women who had a similar story to the person described above, they were groomed so they could get "sexual experience", and sadly for both men and women, the endpoint was sorely similar. And there is a myth that men can't get hurt physically. Too often, in matters of sexual obsession, people get lost in a discussion of the proclivities particular to men or women, and by keeping the sex of the person out of it, I hoped to focus the imagination on healing and recovery.
Thank you for addressing the falacy that lust is not as "fatal" as other addictions. Maybe experience is the best teacher here. Those who have been enslaved know how destructive it is. It would be good if more conversations on this issue happened at the parish level (discreetly of course). Pretending that lust is not ruining lives is counterproductive.
ReplyDeleteThank you for this discussion on sexual addiction and recovery. I love the St. Augustine story. I think sexual addiction is different for the genders; women’s needs and addictive behavior is often different than men’s. Women will seek at all costs that perfect lover then try and make him her own. Men sexual addicts it appears go for the ‘variety’ of partners fir the sexual ‘high’ and require emotionally ‘no strings attached’ which often fuels the obsession.
ReplyDeleteThe use of ‘they’ instead of an honest ‘he’ or ‘she’ is very confusing.
ReplyDeleteThank you for your response to my post. I still stand by a key reason I decided not to reveal the sex of the person; it would have swayed the discussion to the particularities of male or female sexuality, when sex addiction as I have seen it several times over is similar in both sexes, so much so that the complulsion leads either man or woman to very dangerous territory. Also, Augustine did not stipulate that the truth of liberation through Christ only applies to men or only applies to women, rather it applies to both men and women.
DeletePraying to reduce sex drive will not magically make it so. I tried for years, to deal with the inability to get a girlfriend or even a date (despite having no criminal record, don't drink alcohol, don't smoke, don't do drugs, have a six figure salary job etc). Hormones are a thing. People have horrifically forced gays to pray away their hormones to repeated failure. There's also the danger that praying to deal with hormones just won't work and the person praying may "snap" and go down the evil path of becoming a MeToo predator, a criminal lifestyle which one should prevent at all costs.
ReplyDeleteI was raised Catholic but bitterness sank in when I was inflicted with incurable tinnitus 15 years ago and prayers to Jesus and saints like Padre Pio did not relieve/cure it. Doctors pinpointed my tinnitus origins likely to using earbuds for phone use that exacerbated a mild genetic hearing loss in college, a period I was nightly praying for Jesus to protect my health (I was harming my hearing the whole time during the time period of these prayers and didn't know it). But the following has shaken my faith more because now I am wondering if following Christianity harmed not just my life, but another's.
Christianity says that Jesus and prayer is the answer to dealing with hormones. It’s said that getting married is the way to deal with hormones the Christian way. The following is from my perspective as a man, who struggled to get any dates or meet any single women period once I got my Master's degree and a job.
One should be very careful when praying to Jesus for a girlfriend. You may start desperately accepting women into your life thinking they are God's answer to your prayers, only for them to do irreversible harm to your life. I currently am in a marriage to someone from overseas who now has been shown to have severe mental illness, something she hid during our dating period, which has since caused serious legal trouble-and I mistakenly had believed she was my answer to years of prayers to Jesus to get me a relationship, after years of rejection by other women I did meet/communicate with, being treated as a creep (despite always doing the right thing and accepting "No means no"), etc.
People say, "God answered your prayer, he just said no". This is untrue, there is no answer period. You then superstitiously try to interpret random events in your life as an answer to your prayer, and let your guard down accepting the 1st woman who seemingly accepts you as an answer to your prayer, not knowing what kind of harm that person can do until it's too late, and the years of desperation and praying made you so vulnerable and so hormonally compromised your decision making capability in regards to dating/relationships is basically damaged.
I'd recommend men struggling to see an escort where it's legal to help deal with hormones but even with protection getting herpes (which has no cure) can be a risk. Christianity says it's sinful but honestly it is something I wish I had done now before ruining my life and someone else's trying to do things the Christian way. I'm just being honest, and for me to say otherwise would be dishonesty and also a sin.
I want to say Jesus answered my prayers in a good way as your post implies happens to people who pray. But I have to warn about the results of what I believed was Jesus' answer to my years of prayers. All I can do now is hope that my wife can get the proper mental help (after previous doctors misdiagnosed and made things worse with wrong medication) and the legal results of her public psychiatric meltdown are merciful. I still ask Jesus for help (including saints like Padre Pio despite earlier prayers for a tinnitus cure not answered) and am waiting for answers, but I can't forget that what I believed were Jesus' answers to previous prayers in help getting a relationship led to the current bad situation.
Don’t want to contradict but am honestly explaining what I've experienced. If you still wish to pray for me and my wife, please do so, because she needs the prayers. Thanks
Thank you for sharing this. I empathize more than I can say, and will pray for you and your wife. Your prayers were answered with more crosses, not less.
DeleteI will, however, say that the idea of recommending prostitution is entirely destructive, and direly sinful. Please reconsider before advising another man to take such a move. Were your prayers answered differently, you may not be of the mind that it is acceptable to give this direction. Also, you did not go down the route of prostitution, but perhaps had you done so, you would have had a worse life than you thought possible.
I will pray for you and your wife to find a holy priest.
Dear SidV88, I received your most recent comment and see you reiterate your original position. I am not going to publish it; I have already answered you. If you wish to have a dialogue like you have sought here, perhaps set up your own blog and invite comments. But for what it is worth, I believe you still need to seek a good priest who can hear both sides; yours and your wife's.
DeleteNevertheless, prayers will continue. Yours in Christ, Mary O'Regan